How many wars have been fought where one or both sides haven't firmly believed that God was aligned with them? How many militaries in the world don't teach, overtly or subtly, that they are dong the work of God? A few, perhaps, but not many -- everyone seems convinced that God is on their side whenever they go to war and engage in the difficult task of slaughtering other human beings.
Indeed, is there any time that people are more convinced of having God on their side but when they are killing other humans in large numbers? This should tell us something about the nature of the relationship between people and the gods they worship -- which is to say, about theists themselves since the gods they worship exist nowhere but their own minds.
A forum member writes:
Letters bequeathed to the National Library of Scotland reveal that Earl Haig commander of British forces in France during World War I, firmly believed that God was on his side on the eve of the battle of the Somme. As it would turn out the first day of the Somme would be the deadliest single day for British arms in its history.
Amazingly the general revealed detailed battle plans in letters to his wife and when a military censor attempted to block the information he was relieved of his post.
When it comes to military matters, it often seems as though people think that God is on their side -- and specifically, that God will help them slaughter as many of the opposing side as is necessary in order to achieve complete victory.
Is this image of God consistent with traditional theology that people usually adhere to? If God really wanted one side to win, why would a war even be necessary?
Add your thoughts to the comments here or join the ongoing discussion in the forum.
No comments:
Post a Comment